In the age of digital learning and student-driven reviews, platforms like Rate My Professor have become go-to sources for college students trying to plan their semesters. But how reliable are these reviews really? Do they reflect the actual classroom experience or just frustrated students venting?
In this article, we explore this topic through the lens of a real student’s journey—a biology major who had no choice but to enroll in a class with a professor who had a poor rating on Rate My Professor. Despite the overwhelmingly negative feedback, their experience turned out to be quite different from what the ratings suggested.
What Is Rate My Professor?
Rate My Professor is an online review site where students can anonymously rate their professors based on factors like clarity, helpfulness, easiness, and overall quality. It’s been widely used in the U.S. and Canada, and while it can be helpful, it’s not without its flaws.
-
Pros: Quick insight into teaching style, workload, and student experience.
-
Cons: Often emotionally biased, outdated reviews, small sample sizes.
Case Study: Facing a “Bad” Professor with No Alternatives
Imagine being a college student juggling a tight academic schedule. You need one specific 200-level biology course to qualify for your upper-level classes—but the only available section is taught by a professor with 81 ratings on Rate My Professor, 31 of which are negative.
Here’s what the student initially discovered through Rate My Professor:
-
Students called the professor “impossible to work with.”
-
Claims that he “tested on material not covered in lectures or the textbook.”
-
Complaints about poor availability and unresponsive behavior.
With financial aid, honors credits, and graduation timeline on the line, the student had no option but to enroll—and brace for the worst.
The Reality: Beyond the Ratings
After completing the course, the student gave a much more balanced review based on actual experience. Here’s what they learned:
1. Responsiveness Was Better Than Expected
While Rate My Professor reviews claimed the professor was unapproachable, he actually responded to emails within 24 hours—often faster during working hours.
“If you emailed him between 6 AM and 6 PM, you’d get a response that same day.”
He also made attempts to check in or set future response times if the query was complex.
2. Teaching Method Was Misunderstood
Many complaints centered on testing “non-lecture material.” But the syllabus clearly stated:
“Tests may include content from both textbook readings and video lectures. You’re expected to study both.”
Students who didn’t follow both components likely struggled, hence the harsh reviews.
3. Course Was Self-Directed
This professor’s course required self-motivation. It wasn’t a “spoon-fed” format. It had:
-
Weekly readings and video lectures
-
Journals and quizzes (quizzes allowed unlimited retakes with the best score counted)
-
A short essay and a multiple-choice test (graded complete/incomplete)
This format suits disciplined students but can overwhelm others, especially those unprepared for independent study.
The Real Downside: Accessibility & Accommodations
Where the professor genuinely fell short was in accommodation for students with disabilities.
The student had official accommodations for ADHD and Chronic Fatigue but struggled to get due date extensions—even during family medical emergencies.
This resistance created unnecessary stress and delay, especially given that the missed assignment was low-stakes.
What This Tells Us About Rate My Professor
Valuable Insights (When Used Right):
Rate My Professor is good for gathering an overview—but always consider context, especially:
-
Is the course online or in-person?
-
Are you reading reviews from recent semesters?
-
Are there patterns or one-off complaints?
Not Always Fair or Balanced:
In many cases, negative reviews come from:
-
Students not reading the syllabus
-
Poor time management
-
Personal frustration rather than constructive criticism
Pro Tips Before Choosing a Professor
If you’re browsing Rate My Professor, here’s how to make smarter decisions:
-
Look for consistent patterns, not emotional rants.
-
Check if the reviews are recent and relevant.
-
Compare reviews across multiple platforms (Reddit, campus forums, or classmates).
-
Talk to your academic advisor for input on tough professors.
-
Trust your strengths: If you’re self-motivated, a “tough” teacher might not be bad for you.
Student Advice: Should You Trust Rate My Professor?
“Rate My Professor freaked me out, but in the end, I got an A. The class was hard, yes—but fair. Reviews told part of the truth, but not all of it.”
This quote from the student sums it up well: don’t blindly trust the platform. Use it as one tool in your academic toolkit, but not the only one.
Final Verdict: Is Rate My Professor Worth It?
Yes, with caution. Use it to:
-
Identify trends
-
Check recent feedback
-
Understand what kind of learner the professor prefers
But don’t rely on it alone. Always consider your learning style, the course format, and whether the review volume is enough to paint a complete picture.
FAQs About Rate My Professor
Q: Are professors aware of Rate My Professor reviews?
A: Yes, many professors are aware and check them. However, they have no control over the ratings and can’t respond.
Q: Can I trust Rate My Professor reviews?
A: Partially. They’re helpful, but often reflect extremes—either love or hate.
Q: Are Rate My Professor reviews anonymous?
A: Yes. Students submit reviews without revealing their identity.
Q: What should I do if I have no choice but to take a poorly rated professor?
A: Prepare early, read the syllabus, study consistently, and use tutoring or academic support services.
Conclusion
Platforms like Rate My Professor can provide helpful context, but they are not the full story. Always combine student reviews with your own learning style, course requirements, and academic goals. In the end, the professor might surprise you—for better or worse.
